In Stolen Focus, Hari doesn't just blame screens and social media for our inability to focus; poor diet and pollution also play a role, along with general exhaustion and poor sleep. He also points out that it's not just personal weakness that makes us vulnerable to eternal scrolling and constant phone-checking; these technologies are being specifically designed to be addictive. I think Hari is being optimistic in calling for an end to 'surveillance captialism.' There is just too much money tied up in advertising, and though he admits that any solution will rely on government regulation, I honestly can't see that happening either, which is a bit depressing.
Hari also takes a couple of chapters to reflect on the way we are robbing our children of the chance for mind-wandering (my own childhood was basically reading and mind-wandering), by scheduling every minute of activity and removing free play from our education systems. As far as I know, things haven't gone quite so far here in Australia as they have in the US and UK, but we are certainly heading down the same road with a focus on competitive testing and a move away from unsupervised play.
Stolen Focus is a sobering read, but I was relieved to note that I'm already following a lot of Hari's advice. I make a lot of time for reading (books!), I don't spend much time mired in social media, I strive to achieve a 'flow state' while I'm working, I let my mind wander. But as he points out, individual efforts aren't enough to solve this social crisis, in a time when we need more deep thinking and imaginative solutions than ever before. I'm afraid it might be too late to go back.
I read this last year, and like you found it sobering. I kept banging on to friends about their social media addictions until they got very cross with me! Like you, I also deliberately seek out that 'flow' state. I think I've been writing for so long that it's a bit like riding a bike now; I hop on and I'm off for a ride. I agree with those experts who say it's good for kids to be bored; as long as the environment is supportive, it makes them figure out things to do.
ReplyDeleteI definitely let my kids be bored! I saw a comment from one poor mum who felt so guilty that she wasn't able to take her kids out every day of the holidays to 'make memories.' As a kid I would have HATED that!
ReplyDelete