I picked up this omnibus edition of E. Nesbit's Psammead trilogy a looong time ago at a library book sale. As a child, Five Children and It and The Phoenix and the Carpet were my favourite Nesbit novels (after The Railway Children) and I read them both many times. I was quietly devastated when I tried to read them to my girls and they just didn't take -- I might have tried too early.
Anyway, for some reason, I wasn't as fond of The Story of the Amulet, though it was a time travel story and contained lots of the same elements as the other two stories: the same cast of children, the same sly humour, the same absorbing magic, and the delightfully grumpy Psammead.
But... I was surprised and dismayed to note how the story is marred by several instances of really gratuitous anti-Semitism. Did I pick up on that as a child reader? I think I actually did, and it made me so uneasy that I didn't return.
I decided to re-read this time because the elder daughter and I have just finished reading a 1940s book about archaeology* which has proved to be surprisingly engaging (it was a classic of its time, apparently, and may have kick-started the Indiana Jones trope of the archaeologist as adventurer), and took us to Babylon, ancient Egypt, Tyre and even the destruction of Atlantis. And apart from the gross and disappointing anti-Semitism, which was completely unnecessary to the plot, The Story of the Amulet is great.
Another episode I had forgotten was the chaotic visit of the Babylonian Queen to Victorian London, which surely must have 'influenced' a very similar scene in CS Lewis's The Magician's Nephew, though the figure of Jadis is more chilling than the flighty young Queen.
*Gods, Graves and Scholars by C.W. Ceram, 1949. Apparently Ceram is the pseudonym of a former Nazi propagandist -- I bet he was successful, he writes really well, even translated from German.
26.9.19
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I read a few Nesbits when I was young 'because they were there' but never really loved them. But my daughter read the 'Five Children And It' and enjoyed it enough that she went in to school on Book Day dressed up as It.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad to hear that E. Nesbit is still capable of gathering new fans, she was such a genius in so many ways (though a flawed one, obviously). Edward Eager made a point of referencing her in all his own magic books (though I guess Eager is probably off the radar now too).
ReplyDeleteAs it happens we've got all of Eager's books - my OH loves them and hoped the children would read them but they never did:(
DeleteI've managed to collect most of Eager's books (when the library got rid of them, sadly). I started with The Time Garden, which I loved. The only one I don't have is Half Magic.
ReplyDeleteIn the UK they're in print and available on Amazon. Is that not so in Australia?
DeleteOh no, they are still available, I'm just a tight-arse and prefer to hunt second hand :)
ReplyDelete